Damned If I Do Ya, Damned If I Don't

Alex pushed me back onto the bed and climbed on top of me. He kissed down my jawline and onto my neck. I moaned quietly. I felt him smile against my skin. He moved back to my lips, kissing me furiously. I slid his shirt off over his head and threw it on my bedroom floor. He proceeded to do the same with mine. I slid my hands down his chest to his jeans and undid his button and zipper. Just as I was about to take his pants off, Olivia walked in.
 

"Oh, uh, sorry for interrupting. Continue" She said and walked out. Alex got off of me and slid his shirt back on as I did the same. I walked down stairs to find Olivia in the kitchen getting out the drinks. She looked upset.
"Liv, what's wrong?" I asked her
"Nothing, I'm fine" she said wiping her nose and sniffling. She didn't sound fine.
"I know that's not true, so tell me what's wrong?" I asked moving towards her
"Natalie, I'm fine, seriously, just forget it" She said moving past me into the living room.
"Olivia just tell me what is wrong. I am your best friend, I can tell when something is wrong" I said moving to give her a hug. She moved away.
"Yeah? Well, if you were such a good best friend, then you could tell that I am in love with Alex!" She yelled at me. She immediately regretted telling me that by the expression on her face.
"WHAT? Why didn't you say anything? Oh, Liv shit, I am so sorry for what happened up there, I didn-"
"Save it Natalie, just forget it, I am going" She said and turned away. She started walking out the door so I followed her.
"Olivia Rose Perry! Get back here right now!" I yelled at her
"Just leave me alone Natalie. Please" She said and walked away. I yelled for Alex, but he didn't respond. I kept calling his name, but he wasn't answering. I started having a panic attack. I started shaking and then I blacked out.

I woke up a couple of hours later in my bed with something warm against my skin. It was Alex. I turned around to face him. I snuggled in closer tohim. He responed by opening his arms and embracing me. I rested my head in the crook of his neck. And then I moved away from him.
"Natalie, what's wrong?" He asked confused.
"Where were you?" I shouted at him
"What do you mean?" He said, looking at me lost.
"When I was calling out for you! You didn't respond! I was so scared! I was scared that he-he would c-come back f-f-for me" I started shaking again. Alex reached for me and held me in his arms. 
"Nat, I am so sorry. I started coming down the stairs and I heard Olivia crying and you comforting her so I let you guys go. I went to the bathroom and when I came out to check on you guys, I heard nothing and saw no one. So I went outside and you were on the ground, so I carried you upstairs and got you dressed. I am so sorry Natalie" He explained to me, while stroking ym hair. I twas quite relaxing. we got back under the cover and moved back to how we were originally- Alex hugging me while I had my head in his neck.
"Goodnight Alex" I whispered into his neck. I felt the goosebumps rise on his neck and down his body.
"Goodnight Natalie" He whispered in my ear. Goosebumps rose on my entire body and a shiver went down my spine. We fell asleep like that and it was perfect. Until my alarm woke us up for school.

A/N: If you guys hadn't already noticed, I am using songs by my favourite bands as chapter titles. All my heart is a song by Sleeping with Sirens, Do it now, remember it later is also by Sleeping with Sirens and Damned If I do ya, Damned If I don't is by All Time Low. The title of my story is from a Fall Out Boy song. Also, please comment on what you guys think so far and what you think will happen :)